Collection of review remarks

Created by: heluna

I played a little arround and want to leave some notes and questions:

• depending on the curation policy (not yet known to me): How do you make sure, that a keyword for allocation to a Helmholtz research area (e.g. Earth and Environmen) is actually assigned? I guess you use that for the discovery filter on the main page?

Software discovery page:

• I'd recommend to place another page shifter (1–12 of 20< >) at the bottom of the overview, or automatically load more entries when scolling down. I initally thought the first 12 were all entries. https://github.com/research-software-directory/RSD-as-a-service/issues/446
• Are there going to be a more elaborated filter options (e.g. facetted filters based on keywords, license, organisation - or any othe structured information available)? I remember in the NL version there has something been like that - but I can't find it there anymore.

Software entry form:

• if I enter keyword (existing or new), they are currently not saved
• maybe there is also a controlled vocabulary for the "role" of people contributing you could use? (e.g like from DataCite Contributor Role or ISO19115 CI_RoleCode ) https://github.com/research-software-directory/RSD-as-a-service/issues/450
• Maintainer invitation: The text in the mail should provide a little more context. At least that "become a maintainer at the Helmholtz Research Software Directory" or alike, otherwise you can just get from the URL where you should be maintaining something. https://github.com/research-software-directory/RSD-as-a-service/issues/451

Project entry form:

• If I add a very large picture, it is not scaled to fit the display area https://github.com/research-software-directory/RSD-as-a-service/issues/452
• like in software form, keywords are not saved
• The ERC classification is displayed strage in the Detail view: I shows some rather meaningless classification code ("PE", "PE10") and just on mouse over you can access the classification name/description. It would be better to show it als "Physical Science and Engineering" like in the entry form. https://github.com/research-software-directory/RSD-as-a-service/issues/453
• What is the difference between "Impact" and "Output"? https://github.com/research-software-directory/RSD-as-a-service/discussions/454
• #27 (closed)
• in the NL version I see that the Classification codes have also a grey background, this seems also the same color in our version #29 (closed)
• when I went away from the unpublished Project, to link it to a published software, it was kind of unintuitive to find the way back to the unpublished project. I didn't expect it to be under my profile picture, just found it by searching for it. I would have expected to find it flagged as unplublished when pressing "projects" at the top ribbon. https://github.com/research-software-directory/RSD-as-a-service/issues/455

Hope that helps, otherwise very nice :)

/edit by @cmeessen: referenced issues